Preventing separation-related distress in a new puppy
The tug on the heartstrings is real. Your new bundle of fluff is whining softly, clearly feeling a little distressed. You may have been given conflicting, well meaning advice. “ let him cry it out”, “he’s just a baby”, “don’t make a rod for your own back”.
The intention of this blog post is to support you and your puppy during the first few months as he or she transitions into your family. I avoid extremes and it is not realistic or appropriate to be 24/7 in the company of your dog.
I have personally experienced the distress created when an owner cannot leave the house without their 6 month old puppy, being consumed by anxiety, howling and whining and destroying property.
The Mission is Clear. Teach your puppy that short separations are safe. Build confidence and calmness during alone times, and set up the environment so that your puppy associates solitude with pleasure and restfulness.
How will you do this? The best approach is gradual desensitisation. It is important that teaching begins below the puppy’s distress threshold and that you pair separation with a positive experience.
Guiding Principles
A big YES
- reward-based, gradual training
- adequate nighttime sleep
- overnight crate training
An even bigger NO
- aversive/punitive responses
- physical corrections,
- intimidation
- deliberate overwhelming exposure
The most important take-away I would like to share in this blog, is don’t assume that learning independence will just happen magically by osmosis. It is a skill that must be actively taught.
The set-up:
Your puppy needs a safe, positive resting area. Allow a couple of days for your new addition to settle and feel secure. Keep your puppy close. Expect some whimpering, whining and crying. Be their comforter; their safe haven and their protector. The emphasis for the first week is on establishing a secure attachment with you. Please understand that your puppy has been in constant contact with his/her siblings and Mum. It’s a scary world without the security of his doggy pack. Your family will become his/her new secure attachment.
From the first day, give your puppy a predictable sleeping and settling area. This could be a crate. Crates should function as a comfortable rest or play area, never as a punishment. An alternative set-up might be a larger pen, gated room, or other safe arrangement. At night, you may choose to have a crate set up next to your bed or in the lounge room, close by.
After a few days, it is important to begin stretching the moments for solo toy play and naps in their safe place, during daytime routines. It is important that your puppy practise being content without continuous human engagement. Provide part of their food, safe chews, and calm toy play, during these times, while you are nearby.
Protect Sleep:
Protect sleep,
A tired or over-stimulated puppy is difficult to read and less able to settle. Have you had the experience of an over-tired toddler who becomes hyperactive when the window for sleepiness has passed. The transformation from sweet cherub to argumentative and illogical demon child is astonishing. It is the same for our puppies.
A skittish and over-wired puppy may well be lacking rest and sufficient down-time. Your puppy should be getting a solid and unbroken 9 hours of sleep by 16 weeks. A recent study found an association between more night time sleep and fewer later reported separation-related behaviours at 6 months.
The same is true for exercise. It is important not to over-exercise your puppy. Teaching calming behaviours through strategies such as “mat time”, “ crate time” and remaining on a lead and tethered to a secure spot for short periods of time, can assist to regulate the nervous system of an overstimulated puppy.
A practical progression for the first few months
Week 1–2: teach settling while you are still home
Teach Relaxation First
Place your puppy in the established resting area. Provide him/her with something to chew or an entertaining toy or puzzle. A stuffed kong toy is a great option. Kongs can be filled with frozen bone broth, yoghurt , cream cheese or peanut butter. The options are endless. The Kong Rubbers take time to consume so are a great distraction. Another advantage with chew toys is that the very act of chewing, gnawing and licking is self soothing and promotes rest.
Sit calmly nearby, so that your puppy can easily smell and see you. Reward relaxed behaviour: soft body, normal breathing, eating or chewing comfortably, choosing to lie down, or a nap. Rewards may be a gentle pat, a loving look and a kind tone of voice. It could be a piece of kibble if you have a food centric puppy. Next stand up, take one or two steps away, and return before the puppy becomes concerned.
Weeks 3–4: increase the level of difficulty in gradual stage
Increase your distance
The next stage in independence practice is increasing distance. Once your puppy is settled and relaxed, stand up, take one or two steps away, move around the room, and return before the puppy becomes concerned. This is independence practice, not a test of willpower.
Build distance first: move around the room, step behind an interior door for a moment, and come back. Keep the repetitions short and easy. The correct starting duration is the one at which your puppy remains relaxed. The progression is incremental and slow. First master the settle in the crate or safe space.
The next step is to increase the distance and duration. Once your puppy has gained confidence in your presence, increase the challenge for your pup by stepping outside his/her field of vision. Exit behind an interior door for a moment return immediately. Once mastery is obtained as you leave and enter various rooms within your home, then you can step outside.
Advance to the next stage only when your puppy feels comfortable and relaxed. Keep the repetitions short and easy. The correct starting duration is the one at which your puppy remains relaxed. The progression is incremental and slow.
Use a phone, baby monitor, or camera from the beginning.
You may like to consider the use of a phone, baby monitor, or camera to survey early signs of distress in your absence. Video is much more reliable than judging from the mess—or silence—you find later.
Look for pacing, fixed attention at the exit, panting when the room is not warm, lip licking, yawning, trembling, repeated whining/barking, frantic scratching, escape attempts, or abruptly abandoning a normally valuable chew item. Set your training goals to before the distress threshold to ensure your puppy is learning from positive rather than developing negative associations
Provide positive experiences paired with separation
There are lots of environmental supports that can be trialed to help with emotional regulation, during times of separation. Try an old, smelly t-shirt as a comforter; keep the tv or the radio on; have a few familiar, long lasting, favourite toys or chew treats that are only given during times of absence.
Puppies are pretty smart when it comes to routines. They notice patterns. For puppies who become worried at these cues, without leaving, put shoes on, pick up keys, then sit down and read; put on a coat and make tea. This weakens the prediction that every cue means a long separation.
Keep arrivals and departures warm but uneventful.
We all look forward to greeting our puppy with hugs and receiving exuberant lick-kisses upon our return. This routine is not in the best interest of your puppy as separations become a highly arousing event. Keep arrivals and departures warm but uneventful. Save exuberant play for after the puppy has settled.
From 3- 6 months: Vary the contexts
The relationship with your puppy is built on trust and stability. Your puppy will come to learn that you will leave and then you will always return. Gradual and continuous daily, short practices of “alone” time set the stage for a confident, resilient little friend. Use practical management strategies to problem solve situations that are not yet within your puppy’s resources. Arrange a family member, pet-sitter, or Doggy Day Care rather than leaving the puppy to rehearse distress. A puppy who becomes panicked does not learn self-soothing through repeated panic. Exposure that elicits fear can make the problem worse.
Play around with different contexts of alone time. Leave your puppy with a different family member, leave your puppy during the daylight and also during early evenings. Are there circumstances, where you might need to leave your puppy in the car for a short period?.
If you anticipate a big change or an abrupt change in household routines—returning to office work, visitors, travel, or a move, then introduce the new routine gradually rather than making the first absence a long one.
The first three months of a puppies life are key periods for of socialisation. Broader, positive socialisation experiences do contribute to building confidence and calmness. A recent review by [1] Dale et al. 2024., reports an association between a wider range of experiences and human contact outside the home at 5–10 months and lower prevalence of separation-related problems. Don’t miss opportunities to expose your puppy to safe, non-overwhelming experiences with different people, animals, environments, and everyday stimuli. Keep those experiences positive; and stop or create distance if the puppy shows fear, withdrawal, or avoidance.
When to get additional help
Contact your veterinarian promptly if your puppy repeatedly shows intense distress within minutes of departure, cannot progress despite easier steps, refuses food when alone, has persistent panic-level vocalisation, repeated toileting only during absences, destructive escape attempts, heavy salivation/panting, or risks injury. A veterinarian can rule out medical contributors and refer to a veterinary behaviourist or an appropriately qualified clinical behaviour professional. Early help is preferable to allowing repeated panic to continue.
When choosing a trainer, ask exactly how they handle fear and separation distress. A suitable professional should describe gradual exposure, management to avoid panic, observation by video, and reward-based teaching. Decline anyone who recommends leaving a distressed puppy to “get over it,” dominance/pack-leader methods, punishment, or aversive equipment.
In my experience, a common short fall when a puppy transitions to their new home is overprotection and learned dependence between a puppy and his/her new owner. It is tempting to over-coddle a cute little fluff ball. In the long-term, this becomes problematic. A growing sense of security and independence does not just happen. Training and guidance in teaching a puppy to be comfortable in their own company is essential. In my opinion, It is your responsibility as your puppy’s primary caregiver. Give your puppy plenty of secure, affectionate family life and frequent, very small opportunities to rest, chew, play, and nap without you.
References
[1] Dale et al. 2024 Canine separation-related behaviour at six months of age
[2] Sargisson 2014 Canine separation anxiety strategies for treatment and management
[3] AVSAB Position Statement on Puppy Socialization
[4] AVSAB Position Statement on Humane Dog Training